Two more arrested in connection with Butterfield death
Carlos Gutierrez and Jonathan Renteria-Marquez, of Carthage, were arrested June 7 in connection with the alleged murder of Daylon Michael Anderson (of Monett) near Butterfield on May 28. Dillon Williams, of Pierce City, was arrested in connection with Anderson's death on May 29.
June 9
Sheila Harris
Jonathan Renteria-Marquez (20) and Carlos Manuel Gutierrez (19), both of Carthage, were arrested June 7 in connection with the alleged May 28 murder of Daylon Michael Anderson (25), of Monett, near the intersection of Farm Roads 2140 and 1078 southwest of Butterfield.
According to probable cause statements written by Detective Doug Henry of the Barry County Sheriff’s Office, a witness told Henry that Renteria-Marquez and Gutierrez were in the vehicle with Anderson and Dillon Williams on May 28 when the alleged murder took place.
The witness reported picking the trio up after they allegedly attempted to burn Anderson’s car on Farm Road 1090, just south of Monett.
According to the probable cause statement, all four then went to Dollar General in Monett, where they got into a white Toyota Prius and went to Pack & Go in Monett to buy gas.
Detective Henry stated that the Pack & Go security video was retrieved for that date and time, and the witness’s story was confirmed. The video allegedly showed Williams in the drivers’ seat, the witness in the passenger seat, and Renteria-Marquez emerging from the rear door on the driver’s side.
The witness further stated that Gutierrez had crouched in the floorboard and was making a phone call to his girlfriend, who was in jail. According to Detective Henry’s statement, phone records were retrieved in which Gutierrez told his girlfriend he couldn’t tell her what happened, because the line was being recorded and he might go to prison.
The witness also told Detective Henry that the three suspects attempted to burn their shoes, hoodies and the victim’s wallet after the alleged murder, “most likely to destroy evidence of the crime, therefore committing the crime of tampering with evidence,” according to Henry’s statement.
Gutierrez and Renteria-Marquez were arrested on June 7 in a white Toyota Prius.
Dillon Williams, who was arrested May 29 at a residence in Monett, where the firearm suspected to be used in the crime was also found, allegedly confessed to shooting Anderson over “drugs and money” he believed that Anderson had.
According to the probable cause statement, another witness who was interviewed alleged that he gave Anderson, the victim, $400 to buy marijuana with on the evening of his murder. The suspects took him out on a drive in order to attempt to rob him, Williams allegedly said.
Renteria-Marquez and Gutierrez are being held in Jasper County Jail, each with a $350,000 cash-only bond. They are each charged with 2nd Degree Murder and Tampering With Evidence. Their hearings have not yet been scheduled.
Dillon Williams is being held in the Barry County Jail on a $500,000 cash-only bond. He is charged with 1st Degree Murder, Armed Criminal Action and Unlawful Possession of a Firearm. A disposition hearing for Williams is scheduled for June 24.
Sheila Harris
Jonathan Renteria-Marquez (20) and Carlos Manuel Gutierrez (19), both of Carthage, were arrested June 7 in connection with the alleged May 28 murder of Daylon Michael Anderson (25), of Monett, near the intersection of Farm Roads 2140 and 1078 southwest of Butterfield.
According to probable cause statements written by Detective Doug Henry of the Barry County Sheriff’s Office, a witness told Henry that Renteria-Marquez and Gutierrez were in the vehicle with Anderson and Dillon Williams on May 28 when the alleged murder took place.
The witness reported picking the trio up after they allegedly attempted to burn Anderson’s car on Farm Road 1090, just south of Monett.
According to the probable cause statement, all four then went to Dollar General in Monett, where they got into a white Toyota Prius and went to Pack & Go in Monett to buy gas.
Detective Henry stated that the Pack & Go security video was retrieved for that date and time, and the witness’s story was confirmed. The video allegedly showed Williams in the drivers’ seat, the witness in the passenger seat, and Renteria-Marquez emerging from the rear door on the driver’s side.
The witness further stated that Gutierrez had crouched in the floorboard and was making a phone call to his girlfriend, who was in jail. According to Detective Henry’s statement, phone records were retrieved in which Gutierrez told his girlfriend he couldn’t tell her what happened, because the line was being recorded and he might go to prison.
The witness also told Detective Henry that the three suspects attempted to burn their shoes, hoodies and the victim’s wallet after the alleged murder, “most likely to destroy evidence of the crime, therefore committing the crime of tampering with evidence,” according to Henry’s statement.
Gutierrez and Renteria-Marquez were arrested on June 7 in a white Toyota Prius.
Dillon Williams, who was arrested May 29 at a residence in Monett, where the firearm suspected to be used in the crime was also found, allegedly confessed to shooting Anderson over “drugs and money” he believed that Anderson had.
According to the probable cause statement, another witness who was interviewed alleged that he gave Anderson, the victim, $400 to buy marijuana with on the evening of his murder. The suspects took him out on a drive in order to attempt to rob him, Williams allegedly said.
Renteria-Marquez and Gutierrez are being held in Jasper County Jail, each with a $350,000 cash-only bond. They are each charged with 2nd Degree Murder and Tampering With Evidence. Their hearings have not yet been scheduled.
Dillon Williams is being held in the Barry County Jail on a $500,000 cash-only bond. He is charged with 1st Degree Murder, Armed Criminal Action and Unlawful Possession of a Firearm. A disposition hearing for Williams is scheduled for June 24.